Frankly, any time I see claims that something removes unnamed toxins
from the body, my pseudoscience skepticism is activated. I've gathered
some online info that I hope will help you to evaluate the "massage
myth."
"The ability of massage to remove muscle 'toxins' or lactic acid has
also been claimed to result in benefits to the healing of muscle
damage and DOMS [delayed onset muscle soreness]. It has been well
established that lactic acid does not cause muscle soreness sensation
and that lactic acid and 'toxins' have no influence on
exercise-induced muscle damage. Hence this suggestion can be dismissed
outright. In addition, human studies have demonstrated that massage
has no influence on post-exercise blood lactate clearance, while mild
exercise can significantly speed up its removal. Since, as previously
mentioned, massage has little influence on muscle blood flow, this
finding is not surprising. Several recent studies have also found
little consistent effect of massage on DOMS. One earlier study, albeit
with a limited subject pool, also found no effect of massage on
circulating levels of the potential analgesic hormone, b-endorphin."
IVIS: A Review of Human Massage Therapy
http://www.ivis.org/proceedings/AAEP/2000/302.pdf
"There's a statement, seemingly pervasive throughout massage education
and massage books, that unspecified toxins accumulate in the body, and
that these toxins can be flushed out by massage. I believe this is yet
another myth that continues to be passed on as misinformation to
massage students. This is not to dispute that there are very real
toxins that accumulate in the body, notably persistent organic
pollutants (POPs) in fatty tissues and heavy metals in skeletal
tissues. However, these toxins are too chemically bound to their
target tissues to be significantly liberated by the mechanical motions
of massage."
Massage Today: Flushing Out Myths
http://www.massagetoday.com/archives/2002/12/08.html
"To examine the effects of leg massage compared with passive recovery
on lactate clearance, muscular power output, and fatigue
characteristics after repeated high intensity cycling exercise, with
the conditions before the intervention controlled and standardised...
Conclusions: No measurable physiological effects of leg massage
compared with passive recovery were observed on recovery from high
intensity exercise, but the subsequent effect on fatigue index
warrants further investigation."
British Journal of Sports Medicine: Effects of leg massage on recovery
from high intensity cycling exercise
http://bjsm.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/38/2/173
"This investigation highlights the comparison of blood lactate removal
during the period of recovery in which the subjects were required to
sit down as a passive rest period, followed by active recovery at 30%
VO(2)max and short term body massage, as the three modes of recovery
used.... Analysis of lactate values indicated no remarkable difference
between massage and a passive type of sitting recovery period. It was
observed that in short term massage recovery, more oxygen was consumed
as compared to a passive type of sitting recovery. It is concluded
from the study that the short term body massage is ineffective in
enhancing the lactate removal and that an active type of recovery is
the best modality for enhancing lactate removal after exercise."
PubMed Abstract: Comparative study of lactate removal in short term
massage of extremities, active recovery and a passive recovery period
after supramaximal exercise sessions
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=8833711&dopt=Abstract
Some additional interesting reading:
Quackwatch: Massage Therapy: Riddled with Quackery
http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/massage.html
Quackwatch: A Massage School Experience
http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/massageschool.html
Ask Metafilter: Does massage release toxins?
http://ask.metafilter.com/mefi/22571
I am aware that massage has spiritual significance for many. I have
found no scientific studies that address the effects that spiritual
beliefs about massage may have on body chemistry. In posting the
information that I've gathered on this subject, I intend no disrespect
to those who practice massage and related therapies.
Staying well-hydrated is, of course, very important. But I have seen
no good evidence that there is any special reason for those who are
receiving massages to consume extra fluids (unless the massage also
involves heat treatments or active exercise that might cause
dehydration). There's no proof than any significant "flushing of
toxins" is achieved as a result of having one's muscles manipulated.
Indeed, although anecdotal endorsements and theories abound, there
isn't much hard evidence of any kind about massage:
"There are many theories about how massage may work, although none has
been scientifically proven. There is limited research in this area. It
is suggested that massage may have local effects on muscles and soft
tissues, reduce inflammation, soften or stretch scar tissue, reduce
the buildup of lactic acid in muscles, stimulate oxygenation of
tissues, break up adhesions, induce muscle fiber relaxation and
stimulate healing of connective tissues or damaged muscles. Other
proposed effects include immune system enhancement, reduction of blood
pressure, central nervous system relaxation and sedation,
parasympathetic stimulation, blockage of sensations from nerves that
sense pain (the "gate theory"), stimulation of blood and lymphatic
circulation, decreases in heart rate, increases in skin temperature,
endorphin release, alteration of hormones such as cortisol,
stimulation of substance P release, stimulation of somatostatin
release, sleep enhancement or removal of blood toxins. Practitioners
suggest that Swedish massage may assist the body in delivering
nutrients and removing waste products from various tissues.
There is little high-quality research of massage. Scientifically based
conclusions about the effectiveness of massage cannot be drawn at this
time for any health condition... Massage has been suggested for many
other uses, based on tradition or on scientific theories. However,
these uses have not been thoroughly studied in humans, and there is
limited scientific evidence about safety or effectiveness."
InteliHealth: Massage
http://www.intelihealth.com/IH/ihtIH/WSIHW000/8513/34968/365286.html?d=dmtContent
My Google search strategy:
Google Scholar: massage toxins
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=massage+toxins
Google Web Search: massage toxins
://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=massage+toxins
I hope this is helpful! If anything is unclear or incomplete, please
request clarification; I'll be glad to offer further assistance before
you rate my answer.
Best regards,
pinkfreud |